Cookie Butter Brownies

Cookie Butter Brownies

I've missed cooking. Summer keeps me out of the kitchen but sometimes a craving takes over and I find myself standing in front of a hot oven, begging a batch of goodness to hurry up and bake. Yesterday's craving can all be blamed on my sweet friend Lauren who recently made a batch of brownies laced with Cookie Butter that I just couldn't get over. Justin was begging for a batch to call his own, so off I went to Trader Joe's. I have to admit that these Cookie Butter Brownies may be my best recipe of all time, so I should just go ahead and hang up my apron.

Cookie Butter Brownies

Cookie Butter Brownies


4 eggs
1 cup sugar
1 cup brown sugar
2 sticks (1 cup) melted butter
1 1/4 cup cocoa powder
2 tsp vanilla extract
1/2 cup flour
1/2 tsp salt
1 cup chocolate chips
2 big spoonfuls of Cookie Butter


Preheat oven to 300 degrees
grease an 8x8 or 9x9 pan 
In a stand mixer, mix eggs on medium speed
Once eggs are light yellow in color, add in both sugars and continue mixing at medium speed
Add melted butter, cocoa, salt, vanilla and flour
Mix until fully combined, making sure to scrape flour off of the sides of your bowl so that it can all be incorporated
Turn off mixer and fold in chocolate chips
Pour mix into pan and spread it evenly
drop small blobs of Cookie Butter all around the pan, gently blend in to the batter, using a fork
Bake 50 mins or until cooked through

Cookie Butter Brownies


Wanna pin it? 

Cookie Butter Brownies

Recipe loosely adapted from this recipe, which was loosely adapted from Alton Brown's. 

Want more Trader Joe's goodness? Check out my ultimate Trader Joe's Cheeseboard (featured on Real Simple and Food & Wine!) here.


  1. My muffin top thanks you in advance since I now have to make a batch of these this weekend!

  2. Ohhhhh man, those sound decadent!! Definitely need to give those a try the next time I pick up a jar of cookie butter!

    Something About That

  3. I did something so wrong. I followed the recipe and they ended up super oily. Do you think less butter?

    1. I'm not sure! What did you grease your pan with? I used the two sticks melted butter and didn't have any issues!

  4. How long do these keep at room temp? Are they good to freeze?


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.